This drink doesn't sound like it should work, but I actually really liked it. For me, it definitely has that old school, classic taste that's a little rough around the edges. I wonder where this first appeared. — ★★★
Quite like a whiskey sour with a slight herbal note from the Benedictine. Better having rested for a minute. — ★★★
The ratio works, but this isn't much more than the sum of its parts. — ★★★
Eastern Standard uses 2:1:1. Might be better with the Eastern Standard ratio. I liked it but Robin thought it was too whiskey-forward. — ★★★★
I merged the cocktail "Frisco" into this "Frisco Sour", which I believe to be a better recipe. The Frisco that I posted used 3/4 oz each of Benedictine and lemon juice. I suspect that 1/2 oz gives a more subtle and balanced cocktail. CocktailDB lists a more complicated cocktail with a mix of lemon and lime juice, plus some sugar. See the NY Times reference (which I added).
The original Frisco simply called for whiskey and Bénédictine, without lemon. This seems to be an unpromising classic cocktail -- too sweet for modern taste. The choice of rye seems prudent, although bourbon could certainly be used too.
As with many drinks, it's good to start with *half* of the lemon juice called for. The lemon juice threatens to obscure the other flavors. But it's a pleasant sip when you figure out your favorite ratio. Not bad on the rocks.