Pilgrim

1 12 oz Puerto Rican Rum, Bacardi Gold
12 oz Grand Marnier (Or other cognac orange liqueur)
1 oz Orange juice
34 oz Lime juice
14 oz Allspice Dram, St Elizabeth
2 ds Bitters, Angostura
1 pn Grated Nutmeg (For garnish)
Instructions
Shake all the ingredients with ice and fine strain into a martini glass. Sprinkle with nutmeg.
Notes
Can be served warm.
History
Curator's note: I have the 02 version of the book, and it actually calls for 1/2 ea light rum, dark rum and curacao, along with 2 oz orange juice. Those were the days.
Similar cocktails
  • Zombie Island Punch — Rum, Orange liqueur, Allspice Dram, Bitters, Pomelo juice, Lime juice, Passion fruit syrup, Vanilla syrup
  • Ron-Yki-On Guess — Rum, Cardamom bitters, Grapefruit juice, Agave syrup, Lime juice
  • Papa's Punch — Rum, Maraschino Liqueur, Bitters, Grapefruit juice, Orange juice, Lime juice, Rich simple syrup 2:1
  • Bloody Margarita — Tequila, Triple sec, Blood Orange Juice, Lime juice
  • Mama Marlowe — Light rum, Maraschino Liqueur, Grapefruit bitters, Lime juice, Orange juice, Simple syrup
  • Outrigger — Barbados Rum, Triple sec, Lemon juice
  • The Rumbleseat — Flavored Rum, Orange liqueur, Lemon juice
  • Harvey Wallbanger (GCNY) — Vodka, Galliano, Orange bitters, Orange juice, Lemon juice
  • Mark's Margarita — Tequila, Triple sec, Lime juice, Simple syrup
  • Donga Punch — Martinique Rum, Grapefruit juice, Lime juice, Cinnamon syrup