Copy

Italian Rivalry (aka Monte Old-Fashioned)

1 oz Bourbon
1 oz Cognac
1⁄2 oz Amaro Montenegro
1 cube Brown sugar
1 twst Lemon peel
1 twst Orange peel
Instructions

Muddle sugar cube in a rocks glass. Add rest of the ingredients.Stir with a large cube and Garnish with Citrus Twists.

Cocktail summary
Created by
Joshua Perez, Middle Branch, New York
Year
2014
Is the
author's original creation
Curator
Not yet rated
User rating
4 stars
(14 ratings)
Yields Drink

From our sponsors

Cocktail Book
Log in or sign up to start building your Cocktail Book.
Similar cocktails
  • Hope Cocktail — Bourbon, Cognac, Amaro Montenegro, Mandarin orange liqueur, Orange bitters
  • Black Walnut Old Fashioned — Bourbon, Orange bitters, Walnut Liqueur, Demerara syrup, Orange peel
  • Vieux Mode — Bourbon, Suze, Triple sec, Bitters
  • The Handy Bird — Brandy, Rye, Curaçao, Bitters, Absinthe, Lemon peel
  • Jubilee Street — Whiskey, Amaro Montenegro, Allspice Dram, Maple syrup
  • Alabazam — Cognac, Triple sec, Bitters, Sugar, Lemon juice
  • Tennessee Winter — Tennessee whiskey, Orange liqueur, Sweet vermouth, Orange bitters
  • Old Money — Bourbon, Aperol, Walnut Liqueur, Bitters, Allspice Dram, Orange peel
  • Hill Country Smash — Rye, Aperol, Agave syrup, Mint, Blackberry
  • Talent Scout — Bourbon, Curaçao, Bitters, Lemon peel
Comments
MOJO1229 commented on 1/22/2021:

If you're looking for a man's drink, the Italian Rivalry (aka Monte Old-Fashioned), look no farther. With its robust flavor from the bourbon (Jim Beam black label), and the exquisite taste of a good cognac (Hennessy Very Special Cognac), combined with light brown sugar to add some sweetness (but not too much), with the zest oils from an orange and a lemon to counterbalance the flavors. NOTE: One level tsp of sugar equals one sugar cube.

As you might guess, this drink is complex with its many different flavors. I think you'll enjoy both the breadth and depth of flavors you'll encounter in this drink.

The only decision you'll have to make is whether you want to use light or dark brown sugar. For myself, I was satisfied with light brown sugar (which was the only brown sugar I had). The dark brown sugar is likely to be somewhat sweeter and richer. However, be you woman or man, you'll enjoy this "man's drink."