Stir all the ingredients over ice, then strain into a coupe. Garnish with the orange twist.

Cocktail summary
Created by
Joaquin Simo, Death & Co.
Is an
authentic recipe

Death & Co: Modern Classic Cocktails

Not yet rated
4 stars
(14 ratings)
Cocktail Book
Log in or sign up to start building your Cocktail Book.
From other users
  • Used Flor de Cana. Added the 2 drops of Orange bitters. — ★★★
Similar cocktails
  • Ellipsis — Guatemalan rum, Tawny port, Cynar, Triple sec, Bitters
  • East India Trading Company — Rum, Sherry, Ramazzotti, Bitters
  • El Capitan — Barbados Rum, Rhum Agricole, Bianco Vermouth, Curaçao, Crème de Banane, Orange bitters
  • Guyana Flip — Rum, Port, Cynar, Demerara syrup, Nutmeg, Whole egg
  • East Indian Negroni — Rum, Campari, Sherry, Orange peel
  • Nicely Nicely — Barbados Rum, Aromatized wine, Navy strength rum, Maraschino Liqueur
  • The Beauty Beneath — Rum, Chinato, Triple sec, Bitters
  • El Presidente (Cienfuegos) — Demerara Rum, Martinique Rum, Bianco Vermouth, Curaçao, Grenadine, Lemon peel
  • Undercover Liar — Barbados Rum, Rye, Bianco Vermouth, Amaro Meletti, Herbal liqueur, Bitters
  • Naval Treaty — Rum, White port, Apricot liqueur, Herbal liqueur, Bitters, Orange cream citrate

Made with Mount Gay Eclipse, as I don't have Scarlet Ibis. Harsh at first. Added another 1/4 oz Benedictine, then a dash of chicory-pecan bitters to add some depth, then two dashes of orange bitters.

I looked at the recipe for "Midnight Mass", and my mouth watered, but I didn't want to go through the hassles of Svenryelsdorn and end up with a less than satisfactory cocktail.

I lacked two essential ingredients for the making of "Midnight Mass". First, I didn't have Scarlet Ibis Rum, so I dug deep into my 20+ bottles of different rums, and decided upon Matusalem Rum (10 year old Cuban-style rum). It turned out to be a delicious choice.

Second, I didn't have Bitter Truth's Jerry Thomas' Own Decanter Bitters. Now I had to be creative, because while I had nearly 30 bitters, but I didn't have the right one. I decided to use ONE DASH of Scrappy's Cardamom bitters and TWO DASHES of Dead Rabbit's Orinoco bitters. Once stirred so that it was reasonably cold, I poured it into a large and cold Old Fashion glass with a LARGE ice cube. I then topped it with a large orange twist (after I had expressed the oil on top of the libation). The outcome was a libation with a smooth rum taste, with mild cardamom and various fruit notes, including orange. All in all, a do-able alternative to the ingredients I lacked. I rated this cocktail variation at 4.0.

I hope others might experiment with Midnight Mass' recipe, and comment on their outcomes. This needs to be done when you have a recipe others have enjoyed, but the essential ingredients are hard to come by (or impossible to get), and are, therefore, lacking.