Caveat Emptor

My riff on the Warning Label from Beta Cocktails
1 oz Rum (Plantation OFTD)
1 oz Sherry, Lustau East India Solera (See notes for a substitute sherry)
12 oz Bénédictine
12 oz Cynar
1 ds Bitters, Bittermens Xocolatl Mole
1 rinse Campari (Glass rinse)
1 twst Grapefruit peel (As garnish)
Instructions
Stir with ice, strain into a Campari-rinsed cocktail coupe, and garnish with a grapefruit twist. (*) An Amontillado or Oloroso will work here in a pinch but will come across as a little drier and lacking light raisiny notes. Lustau's cream sherry is a mix of Oloroso with a little Pedro Ximenez.
History
I recalled Maks Pazuniak's Warning Label from the 2011 Beta Cocktails book and was inspired to riff on it. I subbed out the 151 proof Demerara rum and Punt e Mes for Plantation OFTD and Lustau's East India Solera Sherry, respectively, for starters. I also split the Cynar with Benedictine as drinks like the Filthy Rich and Chachita were still fresh in my mind. Finally, instead of the grapefruit bitters, I utilized mole bitters and replaced the grapefruit notes by swapping out the lemon twist with a grapefruit one, and I kept Maks' original Campari rinse intact.
FRY 2020
Similar cocktails
  • Secret Religion — Tequila, Aromatized wine, Bitters, Crema de mezcal, Bénédictine, Chocolate bitters
  • Swords Up — Pisco, Aromatized wine, Campari, Elderflower liqueur, Bitters
  • Mannish Boy — White whiskey, Aromatized wine, Dry vermouth, Maraschino Liqueur, Bitters
  • Frézier — Pisco, Bianco Vermouth, Elderflower liqueur, Absinthe, Rhubarb bitters
  • The Beauty Beneath — Rum, Chinato, Triple sec, Bitters
  • Peruvian Riddle — Pisco, Bianco Vermouth, Orange bitters
  • Brian's White Manhattan — White whiskey, Bianco Vermouth, Bitters, Lemon peel
  • Manhattan Cocktail No. 1 (Savoy) — Dry vermouth, Rye, Sweet vermouth, Bitters, Maraschino Liqueur
  • Untitled — Blanco tequila, Herbal liqueur, Dry vermouth, Bitters, Maraschino Liqueur
  • Martini de Hueso — Reposado Tequila, Bianco Vermouth, Apricot liqueur, Peach bitters, Bitters