Mahogany Hall

1 oz Irish whiskey, Redbreast
1 oz Jamaican rum, Appleton
34 oz Sherry, Lustau East India Solera
12 oz Cynar
1 pn Nutmeg (as garnish)
Stir, strain, rock, garnish.
By Jamaican rum I mean, in this case, any full-bodied, pot still rum in the 19th century style. Pusser's or El Dorado would work as well as Appleton. Smith & Cross would probably need to be heavily cut with something else.
Named for a house of pleasure in old New York.
From other users
  • Wow. I honestly looked at the ingredients said that will probably taste pretty bad. Made myself one and it is amazing. The pot-still style rum is necessary though! — ☆☆☆☆
Similar cocktails
  • Bitter Mac — Blended Scotch, Dry vermouth, Elderflower liqueur, Cynar, Lemon peel
  • Head of Steam — Irish whiskey, Sweet vermouth, Bitters, Pedro Ximénez Sherry, Orange peel
  • Hoots Mon — Scotch, Sweet vermouth, Aromatized wine
  • The Bottom Line — Islands Scotch, Manzanilla sherry, Bärenjäger, Bitters, Orange bitters, CioCiaro
  • The Prodigal Son — Bourbon, Pedro Ximénez Sherry, Sweet vermouth, Mezcal, Bitters, Hellfire Habanero Shrub, Orange peel
  • Riddles in the Dark — Rye, Sweet vermouth, Pedro Ximénez Sherry, Bitters, Cherry Liqueur, Amaro Nardini, Lemon peel
  • The Weight — Irish whiskey, Cardamaro, Luxardo Bitter
  • In times like these, bitter is better than nothing — Rye, Aromatized wine, Cynar, Bitters, Islay Scotch, Salt Solution, Lemon peel, Absinthe, Peychaud's Bitters
  • A Dry Symphony — Rye, Dry vermouth, Cynar, Orange bitters, Orange peel
  • Bicycle Thief — Rye, Bonal Gentiane Quina, Cynar, Aromatized wine, Orange peel