Montebank
Stir with ice, strain into a cocktail coupe, and garnish with an orange twist.
This prospers with a slightly smoky Scotch or some Islay mixed in with a blend.
I was inspired by the apricot-Sfumato combination in the Smooth Operator that I recently made. I swapped the Armagnac-rye duo for Scotch-apple brandy, dropped the Benedictine, and exchanged the two bitters for absinthe. Originally, I tried Peychaud's Bitters here since they generally work well with Scotch, apple brandy, and apricot, but the balance was just too dark especially with the Sfumato, so I replaced it with the brightening action of absinthe. For a name, I kept the Smooth Operator in mind and dubbed this the Mountebank which dictionaries define as "a person who deceives others, especially in order to trick them out of their money; a charlatan" and "a person who sells quack medicines from a platform."
- American Gumption — Bourbon, Applejack, Maraschino Liqueur, Bitters, Orange bitters, Demerara syrup, Orange peel
- Double-Barrel Julep — Bourbon, Bitters, Rum, Peach liqueur, Demerara syrup, Mint
- CliveQuadC — Cognac, Cherry Liqueur, Cranberry bitters, Herbal liqueur
- Sound of Silver — Rye, Apple brandy, Falernum, Gran Classico, Rosemary, Lime peel
- Bourgeois Guilt — Cognac, Walnut Liqueur, Bénédictine, Bigallet China-China, Bitters, Orange peel
This sounds interesting. I need to mix up some coffee-Campari to check it out.
As to the name, my guess would be that “Colely” is a misprint. Surely with the Fernet this is named for Ada “Coley” Coleman, right? Also, as to the sherry: Maestro Sierra Amoroso is technically a medium oloroso, which means it is slightly less sweet than a cream sherry. Amoroso is apparently sweetened with 10% PX while the East India Solera is 20% (other creams can be even higher), so as pointed out by OP that substitution could affect the balance slightly if used in the same proportions