Last Day in Paradise
Shake and double strain into a Nick & Nora.
Make sure to use the 50% Agricole as it’s in for flavor and to punch up the ABV. You can swap it for Smith & Cross or an unaged Jamaican overproof if you don’t have it on hand. This version is richer and more full flavored than its Last Night cousin.
I had a notion to make a Last Word template drink around rum and the Heirloom Pineapple Amaro. I tried two variations and liked them both. (See also: Last Night in Paradise)
- Last Bird — Jamaican rum, Campari, Herbal liqueur, Pineapple juice, Lime juice
- Me & My Monkey — Nicaraguan Rum, Jamaican rum, Aperol, Crème de Banane, Lime juice, Passion fruit syrup
- Eye of the Hurricane — Jamaican rum, Bitters, Navy strength rum, Passion fruit syrup, Lemon juice
- Fair Winds & Following Seas — Rum, Falernum, Amaro Abano, Bitters, Ginger Bitters, Lemon juice
- Gathering Storm — Batavia Arrack, Bitters, Pineapple syrup, Lime juice, Lime
This sounds interesting. I need to mix up some coffee-Campari to check it out.
As to the name, my guess would be that “Colely” is a misprint. Surely with the Fernet this is named for Ada “Coley” Coleman, right? Also, as to the sherry: Maestro Sierra Amoroso is technically a medium oloroso, which means it is slightly less sweet than a cream sherry. Amoroso is apparently sweetened with 10% PX while the East India Solera is 20% (other creams can be even higher), so as pointed out by OP that substitution could affect the balance slightly if used in the same proportions