Skip to main content

Negotiated Settlement

1 1⁄4 oz Blanco tequila (Patron)
3⁄4 oz Fontbonne 1874 Herbal Liqueur
1⁄2 oz Maraschino Liqueur, Maraska (or Luxardo)
1⁄2 oz Lime juice
Instructions

Shake with ice, double strain into chilled cocktail glass.

Notes

Fontbonne is a green herbal liqueur, more delicate in flavor than green Chartreuse, and minty, but less so than some herbal liqueur Chartreuse substitutes.

I prefer the somewhat mellower Maraska Maraschino to Luxardo.

The original Closing Argument from ~2010 was equal parts Mezcal/Green Chartreuse/Maraschino/lime juice. Some newer recipes use tequila.

History

While searching for cocktails that use Fontbonne liqueur, I came across Chilled Magazine's modified Closing Argument--which is a variation of the Last Word. Rather than using the equal parts formula which I often find both a bit too sour and too sweet with too much maraschino; I dialed the lime and maraschino back so the tequila and herbal liqueur would stand out. In keeping with the legal theme, I considered this a "Negotiated Settlement" to the Closing Argument/Last Word.

Yields Drink
Year
2026
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Shawn C., Fresno, California
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
5 stars
(2 ratings)
Similar cocktails
  • South American Honey Bee — Pisco, Cachaça, Bitters, Honey syrup, Lime juice, Egg white
  • Taki-Taki — Blended rum, Batavia Arrack, Apricot eau-de-vie, Apricot liqueur, Crème de Banane, Virgin Islands Rum, Crushed ice, Lime juice, Honey syrup, Mango
  • Quiet Nights, Quiet Stars — Cachaça, Blackberry liqueur, Crème de Violette, Maraschino Liqueur, Lime juice, Cane syrup, Salt Solution, Lemon peel
  • Southern Border — Pisco, Blue Curaçao, Peychaud's Bitters, Lime juice, Egg white, Simple syrup
  • Daiquiri No. 4 — Light rum, Maraschino Liqueur, Lime juice

The Bitter Italian

1 1⁄4 oz Amaro CioCiaro
3⁄4 oz Aperol
1⁄2 oz Lemon juice
Instructions

Shake, Strain, Express a lemon peel and use as garnish. (Leandro has more recently taken to stirring this cocktail.)

Notes

This is the original. There are variations such as one served at Sarto in Providence, RI that replaces the Amaro CioCiaro with Ramazzotti.

History

Created by Leandro DiMonriva (The Educated Barfly) while working at Cole's French Dip in LA.

Yields Drink
Year
2013
Authenticity
Authentic recipe
Creator
Leandro DiMonriva, Cole's French Dip, Los Angeles, CA
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
4 stars
(2 ratings)
From other users
  • Exceptionally easy drinking; bright and juicy with plenty of spice, funk, and bitterness to balance. A crowd pleaser.
Similar cocktails
  • Country Feedback — Pimm's No. 1 Cup, Celery bitters, Lemon juice, Carrot Eau-de-vie, Simple syrup, Sea salt, Lemon peel
  • Sur del Sol — Pisco, Blanco tequila, Aperol, Bitters, Grapefruit bitters, Lemon juice, Agave syrup, Cucumber, Salt
  • Rio Grande Sour — Cachaça, Jägermeister, Lemon juice, Simple syrup, Egg white, Orange
  • Cane & Melon — Cachaça, Herbal liqueur, Grapefruit bitters, Lime juice, Watermelon juice, Agave syrup, Salt, Lime
  • Salted Maple — Pisco, Bitters, Peychaud's Bitters, Lemon juice, Maple syrup, Simple syrup, Salt

Chicago Mouthwash

1 oz Herbal liqueur, Jeppson's Malort
Instructions

Stir all ingredients and serve neat in a rocks glass. Optionally, garnish with an expressed grapefruit peel.

Notes

Greater than the sum of its parts. Minty, herbal, and bittersweet.

Yields Drink
Year
2025
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Everett Vereen & Brian Kinkade, Nighthawks Lounge, Athens, Georgia, USA
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
4 stars
(1 rating)
Similar cocktails
  • Quartermaster — Fernet Branca, Bénédictine, Aperol, Dry vermouth, Bitters, Lemon peel
Shawn C commented on 11/04/2026:

Definitely true to the name in flavor profile and intensity. I like Malort (and Letherbee Besk and Baska Med Malort) in various drinks, and while this one is not bad, I feel like it is more of a starting point for a better cocktail using a base spirit to mellow the intensity of the rest. The mint/menthol/saffron, considerable sweetness and lower overall proof reduce some of the Malort bitterness.


The Ugly Truth

3⁄4 oz Cognac
3⁄4 oz Rum, Smith & Cross
1⁄2 oz Rum, Zacapa
1⁄4 oz Allspice Dram, St Elizabeth
1 twst Orange peel (as garnish)
Instructions

Add all ingredients into a mixing glass with ice and stir until chilled. Strain into a chilled Nick & Nora glass. Express the oil of the orange twist over the glass, then discard.

History

The Ugly Truth was created as a modern stirred rum cocktail inspired by the meeting point between Caribbean rum traditions and classic brandy cocktails. Built around the bold funk of Smith & Cross Jamaican rum, it is tempered with cognac for elegance and a touch of aged rum for richness. Crème de banane and St. Elizabeth Allspice Dram pay homage to flavors long associated with Jamaica, while orange and chocolate bitters provide structure and depth.

The goal was to create a spirit-forward cocktail that balances rustic intensity with refinement. Rather than hiding the distinctive character of Jamaican rum, The Ugly Truth embraces it, allowing notes of ripe banana, baking spices, oak, citrus, and tropical fruit to evolve from the first sip to the lingering finish. Its name reflects the idea that great cocktails don't always have to be polished or conventionally "pretty"—sometimes the most rewarding drinks are those that proudly showcase bold, unapologetic flavors.

Picture of The Ugly Truth
Yields Drink
Year
2026
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Alvin D (Boston, MA)
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
3.5 stars
(2 ratings)
Similar cocktails
  • Coal Train — Rye, Rhum Agricole, Crème de Banane, Amargo-Vallet, Lemon peel
  • Rum Old-Fashioned (Kirk Estopinal) — Demerara Rum, Jamaican rum, Apricot liqueur, Bitters, Rich demerara syrup 2:1, Orange peel, Nutmeg
  • The Same Dream — Cognac VSOP, Haitian Rum, Falernum, Campari, Orange bitters, Coconut, Orange peel
  • Baguio Skin — Demerara Rum, Bitters, Orange bitters, Sugar cube, Lime, Nutmeg
  • Bark at the Moon — Rum, Rye, Averna, Pedro Ximénez Sherry, Bitters, Cinnamon syrup

Golden Slumbers

3⁄4 oz Calvados, Boulard
3⁄4 oz Luxardo Bitter Bianco
1⁄4 oz Verjus (blanc)
3 sli Apple, Granny Smith (as garnish)
Instructions

Stir, strain into a double Old-Fashioned glass w/large rock. Garnish with a Granny Smith apple fan.

Yields Drink
Year
2022
Authenticity
Authentic recipe
Creator
Tyson Buhler, The Danforth, Portland, Maine
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
Not yet rated
Similar cocktails
  • Foreign Affairs — Rye, Dry vermouth, Campari, Maraschino Liqueur, Peychaud's Bitters, Simple syrup, Orange peel, Orange
  • Intercept — Bourbon, Sweet vermouth, Campari, Apricot liqueur, Bitters, Orange peel
  • The Duke — Cognac, Amaro Montenegro, Sweet vermouth, Bitters, Orange peel
  • Dragon's Mouth — Añejo rum, Bianco Vermouth, Orange liqueur, Bitters, Grapefruit peel
  • Novecento — Cognac, Sweet vermouth, Campari, Maraschino Liqueur, Bitters, Peychaud's Bitters, Lemon juice, Lemon peel
Shawn C commented on 11/03/2026:

Published, added creator, corrected location, added year, reworded instructions.


Further Out Than You Thought

1 1⁄4 oz Gin
3⁄4 oz Aquavit, Aalborg
1 oz Tonic water (to top)
1 spg Rosemary (as garnish)
Instructions

Stir and strain over large rock. Top with 1 oz. tonic and briefly stir; garnish.

History

Created for the Reddit Original Cocktail Competition, November 2026: tonic and wine.
A riff on the excellent Not Waving But Drowning.

Picture of Further Out Than You Thought
Yields Drink
Year
2026
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Craig Eliason, Saint Paul, Minnesota (USA)
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
Not yet rated
From other users
  • Cola-brown. Nose is herbs, wine. Sip has purple grapes, seltzer water, Sprite, and canteloupe. Spices, black cherry and cola on swallow. Some milkiness and moderate layered bitterness on finish.
Similar cocktails
No similar cocktails found.

20thC Christmas Cake

1 1⁄2 oz Gin
1⁄2 oz Lemon juice
4 dr Vanilla extract (Adjust the amount depending on the strength of the extract)
Instructions

Shake all ingredients and place in Nick & Nora glass, Garnish lemon peel twist.

Notes

Citrus, subtle notes of cherry and vanilla, white chocolate, bright and lively

History

This cocktail was created for Christmas 2024: the bakery at my favorite premium hotel released a Christmas cake. The cake was a chocolate cake with vanilla flavoring with white chocolate-covered cherries. I wanted to recreate this taste, and after a few attempts, I finally succeeded, using my favorite cocktail, 'the 20th Century', as a base.

It may be quite different from the flavors Westerners associate with Christmas, but it’s intuitively delicious.

Yields Drink
Year
2024
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Kang Hyun, Seoul, South Korea
Source reference

myself

Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
4 stars
(1 rating)
Similar cocktails
  • Before Midnight — Gin, Crème Yvette, Crème de Cacao, Lemon juice, Egg white
  • Gin Sour — Gin, Blackstrap Bitters, Simple syrup, Lime juice, Egg white
  • Lord Byron — Gin, Mastika, Lime juice, Mint
  • Christmas Apricot — Gin, Absinthe, Simple syrup, Lime juice, Rhubarb, Mint
  • Oh Mai — Navy strength gin, Genever, Orange liqueur, Lime juice, Orgeat, Rich demerara syrup 2:1

Transdermal Celebration

1 oz Mezcal
3⁄4 oz Passion fruit liqueur (Chinola)
1⁄4 oz Ancho Reyes chile liqueur
Instructions

Shake all ingredients as vigorously as possible, strain into chilled pony glass

Yields Drink
Year
2026
Authenticity
Your original creation
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
4.5 stars
(2 ratings)
Similar cocktails
  • Leatherman — Mezcal, Ancho Reyes chile liqueur, Sweet vermouth, Amaro CioCiaro
  • Twisted Tenderness — Mezcal, Bonal Gentiane Quina, Apricot liqueur, Hazelnut liqueur
  • Red Smoke — Mezcal, Bonal Gentiane Quina, Crème de Cacao, Bitters, Orange peel
  • Stranger Things #4 — Mezcal, Gin, Gran Classico, Pine liqueur, Simple syrup, Mint
  • Santana Abraxas — Mezcal, Jamaican rum, Allspice Dram, Bénédictine, Bitters
Shawn C commented on 11/03/2026:

I thought this combo sounded familiar, turns out I had experimented with the above in September 2026, with the addition of lime juice, but that trended toward sour, so I switched to lemon juice and added some Damiana to balance. I haven't named it yet.
The listed cocktail has a great name, and good overall flavor, but the mouthfeel is a bit thick from the Chinola. There are various combinations of related Mezcal/Chinola/Ancho Reyes drinks out there but they almost all use lime, lemon, or pineapple juice which thin the Chinola thickness.


Pisco Fever

1 oz Pisco (40% ABV Chilean)
3⁄4 oz Aperol
3⁄4 oz Amaro Nonino
3⁄4 oz Lemon juice (fresh)
3⁄4 oz Simple syrup
2 sli Cucumber (muddled)
Instructions

Muddle cucumber slices, combine all ingredients, shake and double strain into a coupe. Garnish: 1 skinned cucumber spear wrapped in an orange twist.

Notes

This recipe was published in gaz regan's 101 Best New Cocktails Volume IV. Danny's note: "This is a very potable drink, easy on the eyes and pleasing to the palate. Spiritually balanced! Perfect for Spring, Summertime or enjoyed year round."

Yields Drink
Authenticity
Authentic recipe
Creator
Danny Parlin, The Chandelier Bar at the Cosmopolitan of Las Vegas
Source reference

gaz regan's 101 Best New Cocktails Volume IV

Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
Not yet rated
Similar cocktails
  • Anchor Scar — Blanco tequila, Amaro Meletti, Grapefruit bitters, Allspice Dram, PInk grapefruit juice, Lime juice, Orgeat
  • Gaboon Viper — Navy strength rum, Amaro, Orange bitters, Egg white, Grade A dark color and robust taste maple syrup, Lemon juice, Orange juice
  • Hurricane Franklin — Trinidad rum, Amargo-Vallet, Falernum, Bitters, Lime juice, Simple syrup, Egg white
  • Swan cup — Pimm's No. 1 Cup, Crème de mure, Cynar, Celery bitters, Lemon juice, Simple syrup
  • Aperol Sour — Aperol, Galliano, Herbal liqueur, Bitters, Lemon juice, Egg white, Ginger-Honey Syrup

Golden Plane Ticket

3⁄4 oz Amaro Nonino
3⁄4 oz Aromatized wine, Tempus Fugit Kina L'Aero d'Or
1 ds Grapefruit bitters, Bittermens Hopped Grapefruit Bitters
Instructions

Stir with ice, strain into a chilled double old fashioned glass with a large piece of ice. Garnish with large swath of grapefruit peel (cut into the shape of a ticket if desired.)

Notes

I used Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon (90 proof) to hit the desired potency and flavor--this bourbon has substantial, but not specifically-disclosed rye content. Kina l'Aero d'Or replaces the more cinnamon-forward Cocchi Americano (half and half Cocchi and LIllet Blanc might work as a substitute.)

History

Created in late August 2026 as a Boulevardier riff on the gin-based Aprilia by Kit Paschal, Eastern Standard, Boston, 2012. I keep making the Golden Plane Ticket as a go-to cocktail finisher after testing other new cocktails that aren't quite working for me.

Yields Drink
Year
2026
Authenticity
Your original creation
Creator
Shawn C., Fresno, California
Curator rating
Not yet rated
Average rating
4.5 stars
(4 ratings)
Similar cocktails
  • Cocchi Cola — Whiskey, Aromatized wine, Amaro Nonino, Bitters
  • Rhapsody in Blue — Rye, Bianco Vermouth, Amaro, Bitters, Blueberry
  • Boulevardier 12 — Bourbon, Sweet vermouth, Campari, Amaro, Chocolate bitters, Herbal liqueur, Orange peel
  • Dissertation — Amaro, Sweet vermouth, Rye, Cognac, Bitters
  • Noce Americana — Rye, Aromatized wine, Ramazzotti, Bitters