Just made this for the first time and really enjoyed it. It is nicely balanced--refreshing but with a weighty bitterness. I accidentally misread the ingredients and used a 50/50 mix of angostura orange and Fee's Orange. Will have to try as directed next time. I wonder what would be a better garnish--a lime twist or an orange twist?

There was no garnish mentioned (or pictured), so I usually skip it. But maybe a flamed orange peel?... As far as the orange bitters, I usually do 4 dashes of Regan's and 3 of Fee's Gin Barrel-Aged, although 7 dashes of Bitter Truth is equally delightful.

We've been making these for a couple of years, found the recipe in the book "Bitters" by Brad Thomas Parsons. Delicious drink with an outrageous amount of bitters! When I garnish it, I usually use a lime wedge. But, these drinks don't last long!

Duh just noticed your attribution to the Parsons' book.

I've made it w/ a London style per the recipe, but I'm a big fan of it w/ an American style gin--like Small's. It gives the cocktail a softer flavor. Also, Bittercube's Orange Bitters are better (IMO) than the Regan's/Fee's recomendation

The first time I made this I didn't have hot pepper-infused honey, so I added a pinch of cayenne to my honey syrup and thought it worked well for some subtle heat. I also found that with this substitution, the drink tasted better to me if made with a scant 1 oz lemon instead of .5 oz lemon and .5 oz lime.

Later I got my hands on some chile-infused honey ("Mike's Hot Honey") and it stood up to the lime well. My preferred ratio was 60% lemon, 40% lime. 

The maraschino is delicious addition and the amount is subtle, just right. This is my go-to whiskey sour now.

Moderated this slightly - cleaned up the notes section to avoid line breakage and to clarify instructions.

Serviceable, certainly acceptable served at a bar, although I wouldn't be inclined to order a second. The lemon (mine are fresh Eureka's from a tree in the backyard) might be a bit more than needed for some, but the acidity balances the very sweet and flavorful character of PX sherry. The substantial level of Laphroaig Islay peat is well matched by the rich sherry and punsch flavors. Absinthe and Peychaud's provide some welcome licorice/anise herbal essence. This is one of those drinks that could be perfect for one person, yet average for another (or even the first person) on any given night.

Regan leaves out the Swedish Punsch.

I'm assuming that 2 drops, not 2 oz, of the Burlesque bitters...that would be quite a drink!

Fixed, unless the creator overrules me, but I have a feeling it's 2 drops.

Thanks,

Zachary

yes, thanks

Delicious on a hot summer evening! Didn't have grapefruit bitters; orange bitters worked nicely. Thanks for this recipe!